Complete WordPress Security Audit: Best Practices Explained

WordPress powers over 43.5% of websites on the internet, making it one of the most popular platforms for businesses and individuals alike. However, this popularity makes WordPress websites a prime target for cyber attackers. 

Regular WordPress security audits help identify weak points in your website so you can reduce the risk of attacks. This guide shows you what to check.

Key takeaways from this article:

  • Step-by-step guide on conducting a WordPress security audit.
  • Discover top WordPress security plugins.
  • See how hosting fits into your security defenses and how Pantheon supports WordPress security through its hosting infrastructure and development workflows.

Understanding WordPress security audits

A WordPress security audit is an evaluation of your website’s overall security posture, designed to identify vulnerabilities and assess how well your current measures are holding up.  The goal is simple: to ensure that every part of your website is secure and functioning properly.

Here’s how regular security audits can be invaluable:

  • Preventing potential breaches by catching vulnerabilities before hackers can exploit them. 
  • Keeping your site compliant with the latest security standards, which is especially important for businesses handling sensitive user data. 
  • Ensuring that your website’s user data is protected, which helps build trust with your visitors.

Security audits can be conducted both manually and automatically. Both options have their pros and cons but the best approach is a combination of both. By blending manual checks with automated scans, you can ensure a more thorough and reliable audit of your WordPress site. This way, you’ll cover all the bases and have greater confidence that your website is well-protected against potential threats.

Step-by-step guide to conducting a thorough WordPress security audit

Step 1: Updating core, themes, and plugins

Developers regularly release updates to patch vulnerabilities and improve security. Ignoring these updates can expose your site to known threats, making it an easy target for cyberattacks.

Outdated themes and plugins are among the most common entry points for hackers, so make sure everything is up to date. 

You can check for updates in your WordPress dashboard under the Updates section. On Pantheon, if Autopilot is enabled, it can check for selected WordPress core, theme, and plugin updates on a configured schedule, test them before deployment, and move successful updates as far as the environment your team has selected.

During the audit, inventory what is installed:

  • Record the WordPress, theme, and plugin versions in use, including active and inactive themes and plugins.
  • Check whether each component is still maintained and needed. After confirming no feature or dependency relies on it, remove unused plugins and themes, while retaining an appropriate fallback theme.

Step 2: Vulnerability scanning

Vulnerability scanning helps identify potential risks by detecting common security flaws such as SQL injections, cross-site scripting (XSS), and insecure file permissions. These vulnerabilities can be exploited by attackers, so identifying them early is crucial.

Several tools are available to help automate the scanning process (which we’ll discuss in the next section). Additionally, Pantheon complements application-level scanning with enterprise-grade website security, including isolated site workloads, read-only production containers, managed platform patching, continuous infrastructure monitoring, and controls that make code changes visible and traceable.

For sites with custom code or unique configurations, it's recommended to perform a manual review alongside automated scans to ensure no potential vulnerabilities are missed.

Step 3: User management

User accounts are often a weak point in WordPress security, making it essential to manage them carefully. A good security audit should include reviewing user roles, enforcing strong passwords, and enabling two-factor authentication (2FA).

Steps for effective user management:

  • Enforce strong passwords: Require all users to create strong, unique passwords. Weak passwords are a common vulnerability and can easily be cracked by attackers.
  • Limit user permissions: Regularly review user roles to ensure each user only has access to the features they need. For example, limit administrative access to only those who absolutely need it. The fewer admin users, the lower the risk. Apply the same principle to hosting access: Pantheon's Site Administrator role, part of its Agentic Fleet Management, lets someone manage a single site's team members and roles without access to other sites or workspace-wide administration.
  • Remove unnecessary accounts: Remove accounts that no longer need access, such as former employees, contractors, or service accounts with no current owner.
  • Enable 2FA: Adding two-factor authentication significantly improves your site’s security by requiring a second verification step. Authenticator apps such as Google Authenticator and Authy can generate verification codes when used with a compatible WordPress 2FA plugin, such as the Two-Factor plugin.

Step 4: SSL certificates

SSL is the term commonly used, but the actual protocol in use today is TLS (Transport Layer Security). SSL/TLS ensures that data transmitted between your site and its users is encrypted, protecting it from interception by malicious actors. In fact, search engines like Google even prioritize sites with SSL/TLS, making it a win-win for both security and SEO.

Use online tools like SSL Labs to check if your SSL/TLS certificate is installed and functioning correctly. You can also view your SSL status from the WordPress dashboard by ensuring that your site’s URL starts with https.

Also, make sure your SSL/TLS certificate is renewed before it expires. Failing to do so not only puts your site at risk but also prompts browser warnings that can scare away visitors.

For WordPress sites hosted on Pantheon, the platform provides free, fully managed HTTPS certificates, ensuring your site benefits from up-to-date encryption without manual intervention.

Step 5: Content security headers

Content security headers are another key layer of protection. They help prevent attacks such as cross-site scripting (XSS) by specifying which content sources are trusted on your site. This mitigates the risk of malicious scripts or files being executed on your WordPress site.

How you add security headers depends on your hosting setup. Some environments let you configure them at the web server level, while others require a plugin or application-level code. Pantheon uses a managed Nginx configuration instead, so .htaccess files are not supported, and customers do not edit the web server configuration directly. To add headers such as Content-Security-Policy on Pantheon, use a mu-plugin. HSTS is handled separately by Pantheon at the platform level and should not be added again through WordPress.

Key headers to include:

  • X-Frame-Options: Prevents your site from being embedded in iframes, reducing the risk of clickjacking attacks.
  • X-Content-Type-Options: Prevents MIME-type sniffing, protecting against certain types of file upload vulnerabilities.
  • Strict-Transport-Security (HSTS): Forces your site to load over HTTPS, ensuring secure communication between users and your site.

Step 6: Review security activity logs

A security audit should check what has happened on your site, not just how it is configured. Review the activity logs available through your WordPress security tooling and hosting setup, then compare anything unusual with approved updates, deployments, or other administrative work.

Here’s what to do:

  • Check successful and failed admin logins, user role changes, plugin or theme changes, and unexpected file changes.
  • Review timestamps and the user or source associated with suspicious events.
  • Investigate activity that does not match authorized work and assign a person or team to receive and act on security alerts.

On Pantheon, platform logs can provide additional request and error context when investigating an event.

Step 7: Test backup recovery

A backup is only useful if you can restore from it. During the audit:

  • Check when the last successful backup completed and how long backups are retained.
  • Confirm where backups are stored and that the right people can access them.
  • Restore a recent backup to an isolated non-production environment and verify that the site, content, media, and key functionality load correctly.

Record the backup tested, the date of the restore test, and whether it completed successfully.

Record findings and plan the next audit

Finish the audit by recording what you found and what happens next. For each issue, note the evidence, priority, owner, target fix date, and retest outcome so nothing gets lost after the review.

Set the next audit based on the site’s risk and rate of change, and run another review after major updates, infrastructure changes, or a security incident.

Top security plugins for WordPress

Wordfence

Image

Wordfence homepage

Wordfence is one of the most popular WordPress security plugins, offering a great set of features to keep your site secure. It includes an endpoint firewall and malware scanner, protecting your site from malicious traffic, brute force attacks, and more.

This plugin is highly configurable, making it a solid choice for both beginners and advanced users. Its reliable protection and real-time monitoring tools make it an excellent option for preventing common attacks and responding to security events as they happen.

Key features

  • Real-time threat defense feed to block malicious IPs.
  • Malware scanning and file integrity checks.
  • Firewall rules that help prevent SQL injection and XSS attacks.
  • Live traffic monitoring to see real-time activity on your site, including login attempts and security incidents.

The free version of Wordfence comes with basic features. The premium plans start at $149 per year for one site and offer extra features such as real-time firewall rules and malware signatures.

Sucuri

Image

Sucuri's homepage

Sucuri is a cloud-based security platform known for its website firewall, malware detection, and security auditing capabilities. It’s particularly useful for larger websites or those handling sensitive data, providing strong external security measures.

This plugin’s cloud-based firewall ensures that your site is protected at the server level, offering a comprehensive defense against cyber threats before they even reach your WordPress installation.

Key features

  • Website Application Firewall (WAF) that filters traffic and blocks malicious requests before they reach your server.
  • Malware detection and removal, with built-in site scanning to catch vulnerabilities.
  • Detailed security auditing and monitoring tools to review changes and detect potential threats.
  • DDoS protection to prevent distributed attacks that overwhelm your server.

You can use the free basic version of Sucuri for security auditing and malware scanning. There are also premium plans starting at $229 per year for one site on the Basic Platform plan.

Kadence Security Basic

Image

Kadence Security Basic plugin listing with login protection and vulnerability features.

Kadence Security’s homepage.

Kadence Security Basic, formerly Solid Security and before that iThemes Security, is a free WordPress security plugin for login protection, vulnerability monitoring, file-change detection, and site hardening.

Key features

  • Two-factor authentication using authenticator apps, email, or backup codes.
  • Local and network brute-force protection.
  • File-change detection.
  • Vulnerability scans four times per day for WordPress core, plugins, and themes.
  • Google Safe Browsing checks to see whether Google has flagged the site for malware.

Paid Kadence Security features such as virtual patching, reCAPTCHA, trusted devices, user activity logging, and hourly vulnerability scans are included as part of Kadence’s broader bundles, starting at $350 per year for one site, rather than sold as a security-only plan.

Leveraging Pantheon for enhanced WordPress security

Pantheon offers a secure, high-performance hosting platform specifically designed to enhance your WordPress site’s security at multiple levels. Unlike traditional hosting providers, Pantheon comes with built-in security features that minimize vulnerabilities, making it an ideal choice for site owners who want to prioritize security without needing to manage every detail manually.

Server-level security

Pantheon’s infrastructure is built on a container-based system that isolates your site’s resources, offering a more secure environment than traditional shared hosting. This isolation ensures that even if one site is compromised, others remain unaffected, reducing the overall risk.

Its main features include integrated firewalls that block malicious traffic, as well as protection against DDoS attacks, which can overwhelm a server by sending excessive requests. In addition, daily automatic backups ensure that even if your site is compromised, you can restore a clean version with ease. This provides an essential layer of protection, giving you peace of mind that your data is safe and easily recoverable.

Pantheon also holds ISO 27001 certification for its information security management system, which builds on its SOC 2 compliance. For a security audit, that gives your team an independently audited standard to reference when reviewing your hosting provider.

If you want to learn more, read Pantheon’s guide to enterprise WordPress security requirements to assess hosting-level protections such as infrastructure isolation, access controls, backups, and DDoS protection.

Managed updates with a test environment

Before any updates are pushed live, Pantheon applies them to a test environment, allowing you to review and test for potential conflicts or issues. This safety net reduces the risk of breaking your site during updates. For sites using Pantheon Autopilot, updates first run through the workflow configured for that site.

Pantheon also automatically applies security patches to WordPress, keeping your site protected from newly discovered vulnerabilities. This way, you’re always up-to-date without having to manually monitor every security release. However, teams should still review security releases and address updates that fall outside their configured Autopilot workflow.

And with Pantheon’s Multidev environment, you can create separate development environments to test new features, updates, or security configurations without affecting your live site.

HTTPS and SSL by default

Pantheon provides free, automated HTTPS using Let’s Encrypt. Once a domain is correctly configured for Pantheon, the platform provisions the certificate and renews it automatically, removing routine certificate management from the site team.

HTTPS encrypts data in transit between visitors and the site, while the rest of the WordPress security controls covered in this audit protect other parts of the application and hosting stack.

Proactive monitoring and alerts

Pantheon includes New Relic Performance Monitoring on all site plans except Basic, giving teams near-real-time visibility into application performance, including PHP execution, database queries, external requests, transaction traces, and errors. New Relic alerts and synthetic monitors can also be enabled through Pantheon Support to flag availability or performance problems. These tools can help investigate unusual site behavior, but they complement rather than replace WordPress security and activity logs.

With an expert support team that’s available around the clock, Pantheon helps you troubleshoot any security concerns and ensure your site remains safe and secure.

Automating your security audit process with Pantheon’s Autopilot

Pantheon Autopilot automates a configurable workflow for keeping WordPress core, themes, and plugins up to date. It automatically detects updates for WordPress core, themes, and plugins, handling the process so you don't miss critical security patches.

Teams choose which updates Autopilot should include, how often it checks for them, and where successful updates should stop. Autopilot applies the updates to an isolated Multidev environment and runs visual regression testing on selected pages, comparing before-and-after screenshots for unexpected visual changes.

If the tests pass, Autopilot can deploy the updates to Dev, Test, or Live, depending on the configured destination. Teams can also select Do Not Deploy to keep successful updates in the Autopilot Multidev for manual review and deployment.

Visual regression testing checks for visual changes, so it should complement rather than replace functional testing, security review, or QA for changes outside Autopilot’s scope.

Implement a robust security strategy: Next steps with Pantheon

Website security is an ongoing effort that requires consistent attention and action. As cyber threats evolve, so should your approach to safeguarding your WordPress site.

Leveraging Pantheon’s powerful security tools, including automated updates through Autopilot, server-level protection, and proactive monitoring, enhances your ability to stay ahead of potential threats. With these tools in place, you can significantly reduce the likelihood of your WordPress site becoming a target for hackers, giving you peace of mind and more time to focus on growing your business.

Sign up for Pantheon for free today and enhance your WordPress security strategy with expert tools and support!